A health-care greeting

Viewpoints

July 3, 2009

Froma Harrop The Richmond Register Fri Jul 03, 2009, 05:00 PM EDT

Americans agree on health care. Ask them, “Who should pay for it,” and they all answer, “Not me.” But follow up with, “Who, then?” and you have a fight on your hands.

Walmart has greatly improved the quality of the conversation with its newfound support for requiring employers to help pay for their workers’ health coverage. Its bombshell statement astounded the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and National Retail Federation.

Five years ago, Walmart led the “not-me coalition.” The name of the game was ensuring that most of its employees’ health-care costs landed on other shoulders.

Georgia complained that Walmart had sent 10,000 of its workers’ children into the state health program. In California and Washington state, Walmart battled proposals to create a health tax for companies that did not insure their workers.

Local companies that covered workers were all for the “tax.” The Brown & Cole supermarket chain in Washington (now The Markets) protested that spouses of employees joined its health plan because their own companies wouldn’t cover them.

An internal Walmart report found that 22 percent of its workers received coverage under a husband’s or wife’s policy. Five percent were on Medicare, and 3 percent on Medicaid or other state-run plans. And 4 percent were insured through their parents or school.

Since then, Walmart has spruced up and expanded its employee health benefits. In 2004, only 45 percent of its workers had coverage. Now, 52 percent do. Walmart has cut the waiting time for getting such benefits and offers more insurance options.

Walmart clearly does not want to become the one on whom others dump their uninsured workers. But as a provider of coverage with 1.4 million U.S. workers, Walmart wants the exploding costs of medical care brought under control. That can’t be done without universal coverage.

In a letter to President Obama, Walmart said: “We are for shared responsibility. Not every business can make the same contribution, but everyone must make some contribution.” The liberal Center for American Progress and the Service Employees International Union -- not your usual Walmart cheerleaders -- co-signed.

Some accuse Walmart of simply seeking to quash a proposal in the Senate Finance Committee that would place health-coverage mandates on companies with low-wage workers. Whatever, the retailing giant is on the right side this time.

Frankly, all the talk about which employers will pick up how much of the health-care tab is unfortunate. There is no rational reason why companies should be paying these bills in the first place. (It’s a fluke of wage-and-price controls during World War II.)

One virtue of the bipartisan Wyden-Bennett health proposal is that it would take managing medical coverage out of the workplace. So would a single-payer, which would move that burden over to the government (and taxpayers).

Although single-payer plans are often characterized as Socialism on the March, it’s instructive to note a new poll by the Committee for Economic Development. Among 300 leaders of companies that cover workers, 36 percent supported a “single-payer” system. (Over 60 percent said they want the government, rather than themselves, organizing American health care.)

A single-payer system makes the most sense -- especially if it’s really a multi-payer system. In a true single-payer plan, such as Canada’s, the government picks up all the bills. In a multi-payer model, such as France’s, the government pays for certain basics, and people buy private insurance for everything else. The French system gets top grades for quality of care, and it would give Americans more freedom to obtain fancier health services.

Ask Frenchmen, “Who pays for health care?” and only the destitute could honestly answer, “Not me.” That’s the way it should be here, too.

To find out more about Froma Harrop, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at www.creators.com.

DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.

Text Only

Viewpoints

Republicans are making some noise
FRANKFORT — Last week’s news was mostly about Tuesday’s primary election but some Republicans who were not on the ballot also had interesting things to say.

May 26, 2012 1 Photo
Taking our Sunday night baths
There in the head of Blair Branch, when I was growing up in the 1950s and ‘60s, we always took our weekly baths, even during cold weather, every Sunday night, whether we needed one or not.

May 24, 2012 1 Photo
Obama pursues higher tax rates
In the run-up to this weekend’s G-8 summit at Camp David, journalists have unfavorably compared European “austerity” with Barack Obama’s economic policies.
European spending cuts, the argument goes, have hurt people and are arousing political opposition, while Obama’s proposals to keep federal spending at 24 percent of gross domestic product indefinitely are likely to succeed.

May 21, 2012 1 Photo
Graduation day
It’s that time of year. What’s the old song? “I can still remember...” And I do. It’s what I talk about when I’m invited to be a graduation speaker and what I write about every year at this time.
It’s about all those painful memories.

May 18, 2012 1 Photo
Recent news could cause panic for Obama campaign
Is it panic time at Obama headquarters in Chicago? You might get that impression from watching events – and the polls – over the past few weeks.

May 17, 2012 1 Photo
EPA goes medieval on Kentucky coal
EPA goes medieval on KRoman legions? Horrific crucifixions? Sacking dissenters and making examples out of their deaths?
These may sound like some of the gruesome tactics used by military commanders of the ancient world, but according to Al Armendariz, who, until recently, was regional administrator for the Environmental Protection Agency, it’s much more relevant to modern America than we’d care to believe.

May 13, 2012 1 Photo
Don’t just pick out a card
When Anna Jarvis launched the movement for a Mother’s Day observance in 1908, her intention was to have everyone write their mother a letter, putting some thought and sincerity into thanking and telling her what she had meant to them.
Unsurprisingly, the idea caught on quickly and became very popular. But, Jarvis was disappointed with the outcome.

May 12, 2012 1 Photo
Returning to a calmer situation
FRANKFORT – After a two-month absence, I’ve returned to Frankfort where things seem calmer than when I left.

May 11, 2012 1 Photo
Saturday night with Bea
“They made me feel so small.”
Bea does my nails. I found her because she works seven days a week until 8 at night.
She sits at the front table, which in the world of Vietnamese nail salons means the money is in her drawer, and she’s the one who makes sure everyone gets their fair share of business.

May 10, 2012 1 Photo
Why are we in the dumps, again?
The many positive comments readers and friends have given my weekly column have motivated me to keep writing it.

May 5, 2012 1 Photo
More Viewpoints Headlines

Viewpoints

Search Results

A health-care greeting

A recent health ranking listed Madison County as the 20th healthiest county in the state. It measured factors such as exercise, access to health care and smoking. Do you smoke cigarettes?

Site Map