A recent order adopted by the Richmond City Commission involving prayer before public meetings is a bit less libelous, but still has a few problems, said William Sharp, attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Kentucky.
The invocation was taken off the city commission agendas after receiving an Aug. 31 notice from the ACLU.
“While the ACLU of Kentucky strongly supports the rights of individuals to freely exercise their chosen religion, we also believe that government officials — when acting in their official capacities — are required to observe constitutional limitations upon their ability to engage in behavior that has the purpose or effect of endorsing religion,” the letter reads.
The ACLU referred to the commission’s action as “legislative prayer.”
The order adopted Tuesday includes several steps to try to ensure there is no violation of constitutional rights.
“The invocation shall not be listed or recognized as an agenda item for the meeting or as part of the public business,” the order reads. “No member of the commission, no employee of the city, and no other person in attendance at any meeting shall be required to participate in any invocation as may be offered prior to the commencement of a meeting.”
The fourth step mandates that the invocation be delivered by a community volunteer who is a member of the clergy in Madison County, and dictates how the city should go about making sure all clergy members are invited.
The order calls upon the city clerk to compile an up-to-date list of all local clergy members using the Yellow Pages and the church directory featured in Saturday editions of the Richmond Register.
This list also should contain a contact person for each church/entity, and be updated on an annual basis.
“The city, nor its officers or employees, shall not engage in any prior inquiry, review of, or involvement in, the content of any invocation to be delivered,” the order reads. “Shortly before the opening gavel that officially begins the meeting, the mayor shall introduce the invocation speaker and invite only those who wish to do so to participate in the invocation.”
A disclaimer will be placed on all city commission agendas that reads: “Any invocation that may be offered before the official start of the commission meeting shall be the voluntary offering of a private citizen. The views or beliefs expressed by the invocation speaker have not been previously reviewed or approved by the commission, and the commission does not endorse the religious beliefs or views of this, or any other speaker.”
The commission’s new order “ ... does represent an improvement from earlier practices, but still falls short given the inherent problems raised by its implementation,” Sharp said. “For example, the City’s order requires that invitations to participate must state that ‘in order to maintain a spirit of respect and ecumenism, the Commission requests only that the invocation opportunity not be exploited as an effort to convert others to a particular faith, nor to disparage any faith or belief different than that of the invocation speaker.’ In doing so, the commission appears to reserve for itself some degree of editorial control over the content of the invocations despite specifically disclaiming such control elsewhere in the order.”
However, the order raises two questions, Sharp said. Who determines whether a specific invocation is within the “spirit of respect and ecumenism” identified by the commission? What are the repercussions for those whose speech is inconsistent with the commission’s pronouncement?
“The ACLU of Kentucky maintains that where government officials seek to exert control over the content of speakers’ messages, it is inevitable that the right of individuals to engage in free speech is impermissibly burdened,” Sharp said. “And if, as the commission states, it does not (and will not) exercise editorial control over speakers’ invocations, what happens when the invocations violate the ‘spirit of respect and ecumenism’ (as determined by the Commission)? While the commission’s order tends to alleviate some of the concerns we raised regarding the Establishment clause, it appears that the order may do so at the expense of the Free Speech clause.”
A recent Letter to the Editor from Richmond resident Beverly Wickersham noted that the Richmond City Commission should not continue to put itself in the way of a potential lawsuit, taking into consideration the city’s current financial strains.
“As for the financial risk, a successful plaintiff who challenges unlawful government actions is generally entitled to recover ‘attorney fees’ for the litigation,” Sharp said. “These fees vary in amount depending upon the reasonable hourly rate for the legal services and the amount of time invested in the litigation.”
Ronica Shannon can be reached at rshannon@richmondregister.com or 624-6608.
Local News
ACLU: City’s invocation order an ‘improvement’
- Local News
-
-
Friday at library : Lecturer to portray founder of Berea
John G. Fee, abolitionist and founder of both Berea and Berea College, will be portrayed Friday night by performer Obadiah Ewing-Roush as part of Kentucky Humanities Council Chautauqua performance series at the Madison County Public Library. There is no charge to attend the 7 p.m. event.
As the son of a slave-holding father, Fee witnessed firsthand the benefits of having slaves and the profits that could be made from their labor. When he graduated from college and enrolled in Lane Theological Seminary, he began to understand the inherent wrong and destructiveness of slavery. -
Berea woman dies Tuesday in Laurel County crash
A Berea woman, Tommie Johnson, 60, died Tuesday evening in a Laurel County crash, according to the the Laurel Sheriff’s Office.
The accident took place about 7 p.m. at the junction of Maple Grove Road and KY 363 south of London, as Johnson was attempting to turn onto the state highway.
Laurel County Chief Deputy Eddy Sizemore said Johnson’s Chevrolet Cavalier pulled out in front of a Dodge Durango driven by Charles Joseph, 19, that was traveling south on KY 363.
After being extricated from her vehicle, Johnson was transported to St. Joseph-London hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
Joseph also was transported to the hospital, where he was treated for minor injuries, according to the accident report. -
Finally February
Ian Rosser, an Eastern Kentucky University student from Lexington, clears snow from his car parked on campus Wednesday
morning after about an inch of snow fell in Richmond. Temperatures are forcast to be in the upper 40s today. Kentucky has seen a lot of rain in the past few months, as was predicted by the Farmer's Almanac, but very little snow has fallen. -
Volunteers needed for equine therapy
The Appalachian Foothills Therapeutic Equestrian Center will be hosting two, one-day volunteer training workshops for those interested in helping others with special needs.
The volunteer orientation days will be Friday and Saturday from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m., but only one day of training is required, according to Mark Martin who co-owns Appalachian Foothills Therapeutic Equestrian Center (AFTEC) with his wife Cheryl.
The all-volunteer organization, which is based in Jackson County, uses horses to help humans deal with physical and emotional challenges. -
Man accused of holding samurai sword to girlfriend’s throat
A Madison grand jury will hear the case of a man accused of threatening to cut his girlfriend’s head off, and attacking her father with a samurai sword.
Russell M. Masters, 42, of Richmond, is charged with two counts of first-degree wanton endangerment, which is a Class D felony, and fourth-degree assault (domestic violence with minor injury) and resisting arrest, which both are Class A misdemeanors. Masters could receive one to five years in prison on each wanton endangerment charge, and the misdemeanors both carry a maximum sentence of one year in jail. -
Arrest made in connection with stolen jewelry, computer
Richmond police have made an arrest in connection with property stolen from two homes last fall.
A woman reported to police Monday that she had discovered several items that were missing from her home on South Killarney Drive and her grandmother’s home on Raintree Drive, according to Richmond Police Chief Larry Brock. The items were a set of gold hoop earrings, a white Sony Vaio laptop, a yellow gold heart pendant, a gold tennis bracelet and a ladies’ wedding band with a diamond setting.
The complainant said the belongings had gone missing sometime between August and October. -
US 25 business owners scared of five-lane plan
Voices of Berea business owners upset about upcoming construction on US 25 will be taken to the state level, according to city administrator Randy Stone.
Several people operating businesses along a section of US 25 gave comments Tuesday to the Berea City Council, asking them reconsider plans to widen the road to five lanes.
The design is a five-lane highway with a center turn lane and a 10-foot shared use path on one side and a 5-foot sidewalk on the other side. -
Grand jury to hear copper theft case
The attorney for a man accused of stealing copper from a handful of electric poles questioned his identification as the same person who took copper from 32 poles two days earlier.
Public defender Meena Mohanty questioned Richmond police officer Nicholas Duvall during a preliminary hearing Wednesday in Madison District Court. Her client, Jeffrey W. Nester, 46, of Fourth Street, was arrested in connection with a Jan. 23 copper theft. He is charged with second-degree criminal mischief, theft by unlawful taking, possession of burglary tools and failure to notify address change to the Department of Transportation. These charges are all misdemeanors that, at most, carry a sentence of one year in prison. -
Judge weighs constitutionality of legislative redistricting
Kentucky’s deadline for filing to run for legislative seats was in flux on Monday because a judge did not immediately rule on a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of newly redrawn district boundaries.
Franklin County Circuit Judge Phillip Shepherd said he expects to enter a ruling in the case by mid-week.
-
Couple recovering from injuries suffered in weekend house fire
A couple was hospitalized after their home was set ablaze Sunday by a spark from a cigar, according to a county fire official.
County Fire Chief Jim Cox said the city and county fire departments were called to the home at 111 Concord Road in the early afternoon. Waco Volunteer Fire Department and the Richmond Fire Department also responded.
- More Local News Headlines
-
Obama Gives Education Waivers to 10 States
Giffords Aide to Run for Her Seat
LA School in Sex Abuse Scandal Reopens
Winter Slamming North Asia, Parts of Europe
Syrian Forces Renew Bombardment of Homs
States, Banks Reach Foreclosure-abuse Settlement
Raw Video: Italy's Mount Etna Bursts Into Life
Greeks March; Angry Despite Debt Deal
Raw Video: U.S. Pullout Celebration
Raw Video: Annual Empire State Building Run-Up
Man Killed in Courthouse Shootout
Air Force Airlines: Leaders Get Polished Service
Ga Girl Fights Off Kidnapper at Walmart
Nevada Highway Patrol, City Settle Beating Case
Homs Bombardment Continues, Global Outcry Grows
Raw Video: Dog Rescued From Icy Colo. Water
Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix
