LEXINGTON — A federal judge Thursday dismissed a lawsuit against the city of Richmond and one of its police officers which alleged a case of mistaken identity violated her constitutional rights.
Debra L. Wren filed the suit in November 2006, more than a year after an incident in which she claims she was arrested on charges her former sister-in-law with the same first and last name — spelled slightly different — allegedly committed.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer B. Coffman entered the judgment affirming that Richmond Police Detective Rodney Richardson not only acted within his responsibilities based on probable cause, but also that once he realized the mistake, he acted quickly to correct it.
“Obviously we are pleased with the result and the court’s finding that no constitutional violation occurred,” said Charley Cole, attorney for the city and Richardson.
The suit stemmed from a credit card theft and subsequent fraudulent use at a Richmond Redi Mart. The fraud victim identified one of the involved suspects as Debra Wren, whom she had seen that day when she performed a urinalysis for Wren at Madison County Drug Court.
With that name, Richardson obtained a video of the Redi Mart activity and conducted a “mug shot” search for Debra Wren in a police department database, court documents state. A photo of Debra Wren was found in the database because “she had previously been arrested and booked for the felony of theft by unlawful taking (“tbut”)/shoplifting in 2002 — a crime all too similar to the tbut, i.e. theft and fraudulent use of (the victim’s) credit card,” court documents state.
Reportedly, the mug shot photo and video from the Redi Mart seemed to match, so Richardson swore out a warrant for Wren’s arrest. After being served with the arrest warrant by another RPD officer, Wren complained she was wrongfully accused and that it was her former sister-in-law who was to blame.
“The facts as developed in discovery clearly indicated that Detective Richardson had probable cause to support the arrest of Debra Wren,” Cole said Friday. “Once it was realized that there were two Debra Wrens (Debra L. Wren and Debora K. Wren) in the city of Richmond, the record reveals that Detective Richardson immediately took action to secure the release of Debra (L.) Wren.”
Coffman agreed.
“Viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, the court finds that the warrant for Debra Wren’s arrest was supported by probable cause,” Coffman’s ruling states. “... Thus, the plaintiff’s arrest and detention were also supported by probable cause. Therefore, the plaintiff’s constitutional rights were not violated by the actions of the city of Richmond or Detective Richardson.”
Attorney for Wren, Brian Canupp, is not convinced.
“Anytime a person is wrongfully incarcerated it creates a difficult situation for all those involved,” Canupp said. “We disagree with the judgment that was entered by the court in the matter of Wren v. City of Richmond. At this time, it has not been possible to do a thorough review of the opinion with Ms. Wren and to discuss her options, including a request to reconsider the decision or file a direct appeal to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals.”
“We do not anticipate an appeal,” Cole said, “but we feel confident that the judgment would be affirmed by the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals.”
Kelly Foreman can be reached at kforeman@richmondregister.com or 624-6694.
Local News
Judge rules in city’s favor
Federal rights lawsuit
- Local News
-
-
‘She wasn’t just a teacher’ : Lambert retires after 43 years at Berea
Scroll to the bottom of the story to read "Love for Lambert: Berea graduates share memories of their teacher," as well as a list of other Berea retirees this year.
Writer’s Note: Brenda Lambert is the reason I write articles today (Class of 2000).
Years ago, a little blonde-haired girl from Rockcastle County gathered her friends to “play school” in a 10-by-10 foot playhouse her father built.
Even at 12 years old, Brenda Lambert knew she wanted to be a teacher one day.
“I always felt like an old person trapped in a young person's body,” said Lambert, who is retiring after 43 years of service to Berea Community School. -
Special Olympics return for 18th year at EKU
Next weekend, the Special Olympics Kentucky State Summer Games return to Eastern Kentucky University campus. This is the 18th consecutive year EKU has hosted the event.
The games will be Friday through June 2. About 1,300 athletes will compete this year. -
Assault charges reduced, dismissed by grand jury
Two men arrested in connection with serious assaults had their charges reduced, and in one case dismissed, by a Madison grand jury.
Jerry Wayne Edington, 34, of Berea Road, was charged Jan. 19 with second-degree assault after an altercation at the Blue Moon bar on East Irvine Street, according to a Richmond police report. -
Dump of the Day
The Dump of the Day is a recurring series the newspaper publishes to highlight illegal trash piles and push local governments to cite perpetrators and get illegal dumps cleaned up. See Page A7 in Sunday's paper to read a copy of the city’s ordinance related to trash pickup.
-
Paradise Cove open through Labor Day
Opening day of Paradise Cove Family Aquatic Center coincided with a spike in temperatures Friday which reached 90 degrees. The facility, located in Richmond’s Lake Reba Park, will be open through Sept. 3. Regular hours are 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 1 to 6 p.m. Sunday.
-
Dump of the Day
An old mattress, a car seat and other debris sit Friday afternoon on North Street between Fourth and Fifth Streets where it was first spotted Thursday. The “Dump of the Day” is a recurring series the Richmond Register publishes to highlight illegal trash piles and push local governments to cite perpetrators and get illegal dumps cleaned up. See Sunday’s Richmond Register to read a copy of the city’s ordinance related to trash pickup.
-
Undefeated academic team brings pride to Madison Middle School
Madison Middle School 6th and 7th grade academic teams have been undefeated for the last two years.
The 8th grade team also has done well, having some students qualify to compete at the state level. -
Woman fends off burglar with knife
A Berea woman used a kitchen knife to fend off an alleged burglar early Wednesday morning, and police say they were able to catch the man in the act.
-
Man is indicted on additional sex charge involving teen in 1998
A man already accused of sex abuse in November 2011 has been indicted on a charge of first-degree rape involving a child in 1998.
Charles W. Peyton, 63, of East Irvine Street, was indicted Wednesday by a Madison grand jury. He used “forcible compulsion” to have sexual intercourse with a 14-year-old girl between March 1 and May 1 in 1998, according to the indictment. -
Woman fends off burglar with knife
A Berea woman used a kitchen knife to fend off an alleged burglar early Wednesday morning, and police say they were able to catch the man in the act.
Officers responded to a call in the 1000 block of Scaffold Cane Road about a man trying to break into a home, according to a release from BPD Public Information Officer Jake Reed. - More Local News Headlines
-
Vatican in Chaos After Butler Arrested for Leaks
Jimmy Carter Endorses Egypt's Election Results
Biden Addresses West Point Graduating Class
Dozens of Children Killed in New Syria Attack
Raw Video: Activists Allege Massacre in Syria
NJ Man Charged With Murder in Death of Patz
Support, Fun for Kids of Fallen Soldiers at Camp
Fugitive Penguin Caught, Returned to Aquarium
50 Years Later, Underground Fire Still Burning
Light Show Transforms Sydney Opera House
Raw Video: Unruly Passenger Restrained in Miami
Raw Video: Robber Uses Drive-thru Window
Raw Video: Dragon Arrives at Space Station
Calif.'s Coronado Named Nation's Best Beach
CEO Salaries Become Sore Issue in Labor Disputes
