Weapons disposal discussion heats up public forum

Local News

April 20, 2007

By Ronica Shannon The Richmond Register Fri Apr 20, 2007, 10:45 AM EDT

Burn them? Ship them? Neutralize them?

The questions that first surfaced in Madison County in the early 1980s about destruction of chemical weapons at the Blue Grass Army Depot remain on the table today.

They dominated a public discussion forum Thursday hosted by the Kentucky Chemical Demilitarization Citizen’s Advisory Commission (KY CAC).

A heated discussion commenced almost immediately following a brief weapons disposal project update given by Doug Hindman, chair of the KY CAC.

Whitey Puro, a former employee of the Blue Grass Army Depot who saw some of the first chemical weapons arrive at the depot, was the first to speak once Hindman opened up the forum for public discussion.

Puro spoke in frustration about the delay in the disposal of the weapons at the depot that has now been given a completion date of 2023.

He also mentioned that when he was an employee at the depot, things were quite different.

“I don’t know what’s going on for sure,” Puro said. “We usually completed the work without permits, without committees and no problems with funding.”

He was speaking about the string of ongoing delays that has delayed the disposal of the weapons.

The first prediction as to when all weapons stored at the depot would be destroyed was the early 90s.

The process has been delayed several times because of funding, disposal and permit classification issues.

When incineration (or burning of the weapons as a means of destruction) was a considered plan for the Blue Grass Army Depot, many people were upset based on possible environmental dangers.

When the issue surfaced about shipping the weapons to another disposal facility, the community also was in discontent at the idea of sending the hazardous materials to other communities and transporting them on interstate highways or by train.

The chosen process for destruction of the weapons stored at the depot is neutralization followed by Supercritical Water Oxidation, better known as SCWO.

Richmond resident John Lackey is not so sure that this is the best, most efficient way of ridding the community of the weapons of mass destruction.

“If you want to hear the other side, I think I’m ready,” Lackey said as he made his way to the front of the room.

He referred to a study done by scientists from Harvard, UCLA and West Point.

“It concludes by saying that this process, SCWO, is not going to work, and if it does work, it will take a long time,” he said. “It may work, but that’s why it’s going to take until 2023 to get it done. The technology is getting better and better, and that’s why 40 percent (of the nation's chemical weapons) have been taken care of.”

Lackey suggested that perhaps the best means of disposal for the weapons is simply to ship them out of the area, stating that it was not that great of a concern to the citizens of Madison County today.

“We would prefer to have it shipped,” he said. “It’s ridiculous to keep it this long.”

Craig Williams, KY CAC member and director of the Berea-based Chemical Weapons Working Group, responded by explaining some of what he said were some of the dangers.

“Are you advocating that we put M55 weapons on a plane and fly them around the world,” Williams asked. “Do you not think that anyone would have a problem with this?”

“I don’t think anybody cares,” Lackey said loud with frustration. “We want it out of here!”

Richmond resident Bill Scott, former employee at the chemical weapons storage plant in Umatilla, Ore., expressed his overall disappointment with Kentucky’s plans to destroy the weapons of mass destruction that have been deteriorating since their arrival at the Blue Grass Army Depot in 1941.

“Here we are, years later, and we still don’t know what to do with them,” he said.

Hindman admitted it had been a very long journey, but he suggested that the community now look toward the future instead of dwelling on the past.

“This whole program is years and years behind schedule and we could spend days and weeks as to why that has happened,” he said. “But, I invite us to talk about where we go from here.

Hindman updated the group about current construction efforts at the depot being done to prepare for the chemical weapons demilitarization destruction pilot plant of which the design should be completed by January 2008.

Almost $2 million already has been spent on site preparation for the plant that is being built in order to both neutralize the chemicals and put them through the SCWO process in order to produce a non-hazardous waste.

The deadline for chemical weapons destruction at the depot has been delayed from 2016 to possibly 2023.

Hindman explained the potential reality of the effectiveness of weapons disposal efforts over time.

“There are remaining challenges,” he said. “The funding has been problematic over the years, and I bet that before we’re finished, it will be problematic again.”

Ronica Shannon can be reached at rshannon@richmondregister.com or 623-1669, Ext. 234.

Text Only

Local News

Trash piling up at mobile home park
Uncollected household waste at a mobile home park on Big Hill Avenue in Richmond will draw a notice of violation from the Madison County Health Department and is prompting the city to clean up the site on its own.

February 3, 2012 1 Photo
Realities of prescription pill abuse spark another summit
Prescription drug abuse has become so prevalent in parts of Kentucky, people are buying Mason jars of clean urine at flea markets and under the table at tobacco stores so they can pass drug tests.

February 3, 2012
Tackling childhood obesity
NFL football player and former University of Kentucky running back Artose Pinner autographed lunch bags, footballs, notebook paper and anything Glenn Marshall elementary students could find (including arms and hands) during his visit Thursday to kick off the Fuel Up to Play 60 (FUTP 60) grant program.

February 3, 2012 4 Photos
Police charge two with making meth
A traffic stop late Tuesday evening ended in two arrests for manufacturing methamphetamine.
A Richmond Police officer working traffic enforcement on the Robert R. Martin Bypass stopped a vehicle at about 11:50 p.m. for a traffic offense. The officer discovered several methamphetamine precursors and paraphernalia in the vehicle that police say were tied to one of the passengers in the vehicle, Curment Nicholas Carpenter, 40, of Lexington Road.

February 3, 2012
Man pleads guilty to driving to Richmond for sex with girl
(Editor’s note: This story contains graphic information some readers may find offensive.)
An Indiana man will serve at least 10 years in prison for traveling to Richmond to have sex with a 13-year-old girl, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Lexington.

February 3, 2012
Berea Arena Theater presents: Kitchen Witches
Performances are 8 p.m. Friday through Saturday, and Feb. 10-11, and at 2 p.m. on Feb. 12 at 1835 Big Hill Road (KY 21) in Berea. Call 986-9039 for tickets, $8 for adults and $5 for students/children.

February 2, 2012 8 Photos
A toe to spare
Pigs usually have four toes on a foot, but not always, Leland “Bud” Bennett of Whitlock Road, said he learned this week.
While preparing the head and feet of a pig to make souse meat, Bennett said he made a surprising discovery after removing two of the toes.
When he went to cut off the next two, there were three. A smaller, third toe was higher up the leg.
“I’m 84, and I’d never seen a pig’s foot with five toes,” he said.

February 2, 2012 1 Photo
Model Laboratory’s annual Lunar New Year Celebration
Model Laboratory third-graders Olivia Florell, left, and Katie Upchurch, inside a paper dragon, wait Wednesday morning with their classmates in the school hallway for the start of the annual Lunar New Year Celebration parade. The students created the dragon after learning about Asian
calligraphy in art class and walked with the dragon, while playing instruments and clapping, to the end of the hall in front of classmates in pre-kindergarten through fifth-grade who have also been studying aspects of Asian culture. The parade is intended to bring good luck and friendship to the school for the new year, the Chinese New Year of the Dragon, said art teacher Denise Discepoli.

February 2, 2012 1 Photo
Teacher turned award-winning author to read at Richmond Area Arts Council tonight
Because Rebecca D. Elswick won publication of her debut novel, “Mama’s Shoes,” in a national contest, it might be easy to view her as a kind of literary American Idol.
But, unlike many of the precocious American Idol winners, Elswick toiled and studied her craft for years before achieving success. Now, the accolades are accumulating, and each honor further confirms her status as one of the hottest emerging authors in the South.
She will read and sign books tonight along with Lexington author George Ella Lyon at the Richmond Area Arts Council, 399 W. Water St., beginning at 6:30 p.m.

February 2, 2012 1 Photo
Project Read helps students turn the page
Steve Hupp likes solving problems, and at 27 years old, he has seen more than his fair share. Hupp has been in and out of hospitals since childhood, making it difficult for him to focus on school. To make it worse, he also is dyslexic.
Hupp dropped out of school in the 11th grade.
“Some places wouldn’t even give me an application,” he said about his search for a job. “I had doors close on me. I even had girlfriends break up with me.”

February 2, 2012 1 Photo
More Local News Headlines

Local News

Search Results

Weapons disposal discussion heats up public forum

Have you ever attended a meeting of a local government agency or taxing district?

Site Map